Mum Philippa Day killed by benefits brutality

Mum Philippa Day. Thanks to Imogen Day for photo.

The inquest in Nottingham into the death of Philippa Day has concluded. Her sister, Imogen Day says:

Support from her community psychiatric nurse and from her family kept her going. But the constant cold and unsympathetic wall of resistance that she met at Capita and the DWP was more than she could endure. The refusal of a home assessment by Capita was just too much for Pip to cope with. We believe she just couldn’t take any more.

At WinVisible, we are battling the brutal benefits system automatically churning out reassessments and interviews by the profiteer companies Atos, Capita and Maximus, which have huge contracts with the DWP. As in Philippa Day’s case, they cruelly refuse home and paper-based assessments looking at claimants’ testimony and medical evidence, which can be done if guidance on exemptions and “reasonable adjustments” is followed. We have publicised these exemptions, see our Benefits help info page.

We support women who are fighting for recognition of mental distress and severe disabilities, who are refused exemption from the stressful interviews, or left in limbo on basic Universal Credit without the disability element because their Work Capability Assessment telephone interview was deemed “inconclusive”. Many others have won their case with our info and encouragement.

Protest at Atos head office in Euston, July 2017. Photo thanks to Peter Marshall.

Alongside many groups and bereaved relatives, we are campaigning against these injustices and for benefit rights for everyone who needs them. Personal Independence Payments were deliberately introduced to deprive around 600,000 people of disability benefits. George Osborne was booed by the crowd at the 2012 Paralympics for this. Matt Hancock was his economic adviser then.

From Philippa Day’s inquest and other court cases we see that the brutality of the benefits system is caused by both the DWP framework and individual decisions by staff. Like the thousands of COVID deaths which were preventable, many thousands have lost their lives and suffered loss of income from the government’s intention to cut the benefits bill and force us to reapply, whether DLA to PIP, ESA to Universal Credit or being relentlessly reassessed for ESA, as with the tragic deaths of Jodey Whiting, and Errol Graham, also in Nottingham.

We send our deepest condolences to Charles Day, Imogen Day and family.

Press release by Leigh Day

Wednesday, 27 January 2021

Conclusion of inquest into death of Philippa Day

“A coroner has delivered a damning indictment of systemic problems at the Department of Work and Pensions that contributed to the decision of Philippa Day to take an overdose that led to her death.

At today’s conclusion of the inquest into Philippa’s death in October, 2019, assistant coroner Gordon Clow said that Philippa, a diabetic who suffered unstable personality disorder, had taken an overdose of insulin as a result of stresses including mental health problems and a growing sense of failure.

But he said the predominant factor affecting her decision to take an overdose was the financial distress caused by the administration of welfare benefits which led to acute distress and exacerbated the other stresses. 

Mr Clow will issue a prevention of future deaths report to call for the DWP to consider and address timely Mental health training for call handers, record keeping and assessment process where is need for review, that correspondence issued is accurate and does not create further stress.

Philippa, also known as Pip, died two months after the overdose following a long struggle over her Personal Independence Payment benefits claim in 2019.

Pip was found collapsed by her sister and father on 8 August, 2019, with a letter beside her from the DWP refusing her a home assessment visit over her benefits.

The inquest into her death, held remotely at Nottingham Coroners Court, was told about Pip’s immense difficulties over her benefits claim and how it impacted her in the months leading up to her death.

As a diabetic she had received Disability Living Allowance (DLA) since she was 16. In November, 2018 Pip made a claim for Personal Independence Payment (PIP) but the application form she returned to the DWP was not received. As a result, her DLA payments were cancelled in January, 2019. 

Pip didn’t realise her benefits had been stopped due to her poor mental health and she later had to begin a new claim.

With no disability benefits income, Pip fell into serious poverty and debt. She already had a chaotic lifestyle and the loss of disability benefit payments sent her into a spiral of anxiety and despair. Calls to the DWP were not treated in accordance with safeguarding policy and, despite her pleas, plus representations by her trusted community psychiatric nurse, it took months for her DLA to be reinstated and she was then refused a home visit for a PIP assessment. 

A DWP agent who took a call from Pip in June 2019 admitted she had not left a note on Pip’s file to indicate the distress that Pip had voiced. The court heard a recording of the call in which Pip said she was “literally starving and cold”, “genuinely can’t survive like this for much longer”, was “in so much debt”, “literally cannot leave the house”, and needed “a reason to live”. The agent said she had heard many claimants crying and saying similar things. She did not explain why she had not followed the DWP’s six-point plan to guide staff when claimants voiced suicidal intent.

The coroner heard that the DWP letter found beside Philippa’s following her overdose was an automatically generated piece of correspondence requiring her to attend a benefits assessment. However a call by her community psychiatric nurse to a DWP call handler had agreed that the assessment should not happen and another appointment was arranged simply to keep her place in the system. The system did not allow for the conversation to be recorded in a letter.

Following the conclusion of the inquest, Pip’s sister Imogen Day issued the following statement:

“As our family made clear in evidence given at the inquest into the death of my sister, we believe that Pip’s treatment by the DWP had a direct impact on her mental state and in the end is the reason for her death. 

“She was in despair because of the depths to which she had sunk, she could see no way out of the debt and the poverty in which she was living. Pip’s poor mental health meant she was not able to handle the battle with the DWP for the reinstatement of her benefits. The stress of the conflict with the DWP made her even more ill.

“Support from her community psychiatric nurse and from her family kept her going. But the constant cold and unsympathetic wall of resistance that she met at Capita and the DWP was more than she could endure.

“The refusal of a home assessment by Capita was just too much for Pip to cope with. We believe she just couldn’t take any more.”

Leigh Day partner Merry Varney, who represented the family, said:

“The Coroner has held a thorough investigation into how Pip came by her death, allowing Pip’s family the opportunity to hear from the call handlers and decision makers involved and question senior staff at the DWP and Capita about how Pip came to be so badly let down.

“His finding of 28 failings by DWP and Capita, some of which were errors made repeatedly and which the Coroner did not feel could be considered just errors by individuals, together with his clear conclusion, leave no doubt that  the DWP and Capita through its flawed handling of Pip’s disability benefits claim materially contributed to the death of a much loved mum, sister and daughter. My clients hope the changes the DWP and Capita have committed to make are done so promptly and thoroughly to protect other families.”

ENDS

For more information contact Leigh Day press office at pressoffice@leighday.co.uk

One comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s